【600 new jersey ave nw washington dc 20001】U.S. Supreme Court justices question human rights claims against Nestle and Cargill
By Lawrence Hurley
WASHINGTON,600 new jersey ave nw washington dc 20001 Dec 1(Reuters) - U.S. Supreme Court justices on Tuesday appeared wary of barring lawsuits against American companies over alleged human rights abuses abroad but signaled they could toss out a case accusing Cargill Inc and a Nestle SA subsidiary of knowingly helping perpetuate slavery at Ivory Coast cocoa farms.
The two companies are asking the nine justices to reverse a lower court ruling that allowed the lawsuit, brought on behalf of former child slaves from Mali who worked at the farms, filed against them in 2005 to proceed.
The case concerns a 1789 U.S. law called the Alien Tort Statute that lets non-U.S. citizens seek damages in American courts in certain instances. The business community has long sought to limit corporate liability under this law.
Some justices questioned whether the lawsuit actually made clear that company officials knew that the farms involved used child slavery.
"After 15 years, is it too much to ask that you allege specifically that the defendants ... who are before us here, specifically knew that forced child labor was being used on the farms or farm cooperatives with which they did business?" conservative Justice Samuel Alito asked.
The lawsuits targeted the U.S. subsidiary of Swiss-based Nestle, the world's biggest food producer, and commodities trader Cargill, one of the largest privately held U.S. companies.
The plaintiffs accused the companies of aiding and abetting human rights violations through their active involvement in purchasing Ivory Coast cocoa and turning a blind eye to the use of slave labor on the farms despite being aware of the practice in order to keep cocoa prices low.
A federal district court in Los Angeles dismissed the lawsuit twice, most recently in 2017. That court found that the claims were barred by recent Supreme Court decisions that made it harder for plaintiffs to sue corporations in U.S. courts for alleged violations overseas.
The San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in 2018 revived the claims, citing the allegations that the companies provided "personal spending money" to local farmers to guarantee the cheapest source of cocoa. The 9th Circuit found that the payments were akin to kickbacks and that the low price of cocoa was dependant upon the child slave labor.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and other business interests backed the two companies in the case, as did President Donald Trump's administration.
The Supreme Court in 2013 and 2018 cases curbed the ability of plaintiffs to sue corporations in U.S. courts under the Alien Tort Statute for overseas human rights violations. The court said in those rulings that there needed to be a strong connection between the alleged conduct and actions that took place in the United States. But the court did not definitively rule that companies can never be sued under that law.
Since the 2018 ruling, which was 5-4, the court has shifted further to the right with the appointment by President Donald Trump of conservative justices Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett. (Reporting by Lawrence Hurley; Editing by Will Dunham)
View comments
(责任编辑:Entertainment)
- A Look At The Fair Value Of Leidos Holdings, Inc. (NYSE:LDOS)
- SHAREHOLDER ALERT: PTLA GERN AAN: The Law Offices of Vincent Wong Reminds Investors of Important Class Action Deadlines
- Video Meetings Can Be Superior Meetings
- Shift Announces Its Intention to Commence an Offer to Exchange Its Publicly Traded Warrants
- Buy Ferrari Stock After Scuderia-Velas NFT deal?
- Wall Street falls as coronavirus shreds U.S. payrolls
- SNX or GWRE: Which Is the Better Value Stock Right Now?
- What Kind Of Investors Own Most Of IBI Group Inc. (TSE:IBG)?
- Brazil manufacturing PMI rises to 38.3 in May from record low 36.0 in April - IHS Markit
- How Avadel (AVDL) Stock Stands Out in a Strong Industry
- Can Ero Copper Corp. (TSE:ERO) Maintain Its Strong Returns?
- SHAREHOLDER ALERT: TUFN EHTH R: The Law Offices of Vincent Wong Reminds Investors of Important Class Action Deadlines
- Wells Fargo CEO tells Congress bank has doubled down on regulatory issues
-
Sick of Roaming Fees? Now Your Carrier Is Hurting Too
(Bloomberg Opinion) -- The Covid-19 pandemic has revealed an uncomfortable truth about the telecoms ...[详细] -
5 High-Yield Stocks to Defy Coronavirus-Led Crisis in April
With cities under lockdown and factories closed due to the coronavirus outbreak, stocks have been re ...[详细] -
When Can We Expect A Profit From Asmallworld AG (VTX:ASWN)?
Asmallworld AG's (VTX:ASWN): Asmallworld AG operates as a private social network that connects peopl ...[详细] -
VENICE, CA / ACCESSWIRE / April 2, 2020 /10 BLOCK, a TV guide for the social media generation, annou ...[详细]
-
WhatsApp no longer supported on millions of phones
WhatsAppwill no longer be supported on millions of olderiPhonesandAndroiddevices starting Saturday, ...[详细] -
ESTA Announces Participation in the Goldman Sachs Global Healthcare Conference
NEW YORK, June 03, 2020 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- Establishment Labs Holdings Inc. (ESTA), a medical techn ...[详细] -
NEW YORK, NY / ACCESSWIRE / March 4, 2020 /The Law Offices of Vincent Wong announce that class actio ...[详细]
-
Grocery shopping tips for avoiding coronavirus
Get all the latest news on coronavirus and more delivered daily to your inbox.Sign up here.Americans ...[详细] -
NeoPhotonics (NPTN) Misses Q3 Earnings Estimates
NeoPhotonics (NPTN) came out with quarterly earnings of $0.11 per share, missing the Zacks Consensus ...[详细] -
NEW YORK, June 01, 2020 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- Pomerantz LLP is investigating claims on behalf of inves ...[详细]
What to do if you're fired during coronavirus
Morgan Stanley Deboards From Cruise Lines, Bearish On Carnival, Norwegian And Royal Caribbean
- Stocks adding to biggest one day gain on stimulus hopes
- Bitcoin falls below 8,000 ahead of what is expected to be a rough day for U.S. stocks
- How Bassett (BSET) Stock Stands Out in a Strong Industry
- Top Analyst Reports for Apple, Verizon & PayPal
- Pennsylvania's Democratic governor calls Trump remarks 'partisan attack'
- Ducks Unlimited Canada commends Government’s Fall Economic Statement that recognizes nature in Canada’s economic recovery
- Company News for Nov 4, 2020